Select Page

The Perfect Key West Gift

 

Key Lime Pie, Key Lime Soaps and Lotions, Key Lime Pie Mixes, Key Lime Hot Sauces, Key Lime Rum Cakes  and everything Key Lime you could ever want.

Shop Now

Key Lime Pie Bakery

 

Watch our pies being made on site in our bakery, right before your eyes. We use only the finest and freshest ingredients, including REAL key lime juice.

 

Visit Us

Key Lime Pie Bakery in Key West

Welcome! Here at the Key Lime Pie Bakery, we’ve been making Key Lime pies for decades! We’re known for our famous pies, made in our open kitchen with real key lime juice in front of your eyes. Come in and sit down, enjoy a con leche, an espresso with a slice of key lime pie, coconut creme pie, a slice of coconut on the bottom and key lime on top or pie bar dipped in chocolate on a stick. We encourage you to visit our location and see why we are worlds apart from the rest. Our friendly staff will help you choose which pie to taste. And while you’re at it, pick up a few souvenirs, we have plenty to chose from. Thank you for continuing to support us through so many years of growing and changing to make our place the best it can be. Thank you!

Buy Online – Coming Soon

What Our Customers are Saying

“The shop actually sells an array of key lime and coconut items, including ice cream, coffee, candy, and even beauty products. It’s located near other bakeries, but don’t be tempted by them; This is the one to go to for all your Key Lime needs.”

Courtney D.

via Yelp

“I love the Key Lime Pie!  I drove 3 hours from Miami to KW by myself to get a slice of this pie and it was well worth it!  Can’t wait to go back!”

Susie C.

via Yelp

“Best coconut key lime pie ever. Hands down, nothing to add. Light and rich at the same time, pure deliciousness. Had a great chat with the shop owner, very friendly staff. Must visit in Key West!”

M.T.

via TripAdvisor

“We stopped here after lunch and a little shopping for a quick treat. This little shop did not disappoint! There are lots of gift items (prepackaged cookies, breads, etc.) but the key lime pie is the reason to go. Yummy and so light!”

Alison F.

via TripAdvisor

Contact Us

4 + 12 =

More Info

You can find us in the heart of Old Town Key West, near Duval Street and close to famous landmarks like the Mel Fisher Museum.

Address: 412 Greene Street
Key West, Florida, 33040

Phone: +1 305-296-9515

Business Hours: Monday thru Sunday 9.00am to 11.00pm

Key Lime Pie Bakery